Diabetes-Epilepsy Symbiosis
S. Janani1, P. Geetha*, P. Shanmugasundaram
School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Vels
University (VISTAS), Velan Nagar, P.V. Vaithiyalingam Road,
Pallavaram, Chennai- 600 117. Tamil Nadu, India.
Corresponding author Email:
lgeethapharma@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Epilepsy is one of the neurological
disorder characterised by a period of epileptic
seizures. The findings reveal that type 1 diabetes may increase epilepsy risk
three fold. About 25% to 45% of epilepsy cases can be due to structural
modifications, metabolic disorders, and genetic characters but early research
has also claimed that diabetes might explain some idiopathic seizures, Dr Chou and
their colleagues wrote. Those people with type 1 diabetes but without hypoglycaemia found to have a 2.67 fold increased risk of
developing epilepsy during medication vs. the other group, whereas those with
both type 1 diabetes and hypoglycaemia might have
about 16.5 fold increased risk of developing epilepsy.
KEYWORDS: Epilepsy,
Seizure, Diabetes
INTRODUCTION:
Epilepsy is a group of neurological diseases characterised by epileptic seizures. [1,2] Epileptic
seizures are episodes that can vary from brief and nearly unnotable
to long periods of vigorous shaking. [3] These episodes commonly
result in physical injuries including broken bones in rare cases. [3] In
epilepsy, seizures tend to recur more rapidly and there is no immediate
underlying cause. [1] Isolated seizures that are provoked by a
specific cause such as poisoning are not seemed to represent epilepsy. [4]
People with epilepsy in some parts of the world
experience stigma due to their epileptic condition. [3] The causes
of most cases of epilepsy is unknown, although it is believed that some people
develop epilepsy as the result of brain injury, stroke, brain tumours, infections of the brain and birth defects. [3]
Known genetic mutations are directly linked to a small proportion of
cases. [5, 6]
TYPES OF EPILEPSY:
Epilepsy is commonly and most widely known for causing
convulsions- sudden uncontrolled movements. [7] But seizures can
trigger a wide range of other symptoms, from starting to fall to fumbling with
clothes. Doctors divide seizures into different types depending on how it
affects the brain. Each has their own set of symptoms and the underlying cause
is unknown.
· Generalised tonic-clonic
seizures
· Tonic-clonic
· Tonic
· Clonic
· Myoclonic
· Absence and
· Atonic seizures.
It results in loss of consciousness and typically
happen without warning. [8]
· Partial seizures
· Absence seizures
They are non convulsive and presents a decreased level
of consciousness and usually it is seemed to lasts about 10 seconds [9,
10]
Type1 diabetes
mellitus is one of the most common autoimmune disorder in children, with a 3%
annual increase in the global increase rate since 1980s.
HYPERGLYCAEMIA IS
SEEMED TO LOWER SEIZURE THRESHOLD:
Abnormal glucose levels, whether it is too high or too
low, can result in seizures. This problem is especially pertinent to
individuals with diabetes, whose blood glucose levels can fluctuate many times
a day, may be due to intercurrent illness, variations
in insulin levels, or other metabolic factors. Clinical studies proved that
adults with hyperglycemia have an increased predisposition to experiencing
seizures and epilepsy. Experimental studies done both in vivo and in vitro,
suggest that a threshold glucose concentration is obligatory to support
synaptic transmission. Conversely, it is seen that elevated extracellular
glucose is related with neuronal hyperexcitability,
indicating that glucose balance is necessary for normal neurotransmission. The
key importance of glucose balance has been found in studies demonstrating that hyperglycaemia exacerbates ischemia-induced brain damage,
whereas fasting-induced hypoglycaemia protects
against this neurotoxicity. The present study, by Schechter and co-workers,
hypothesizes that the reduction of extracellular glucose could ameliorate
seizure activity by decreasing neuronal excitability.
First, Schwechter et al.
Examined that the relation between extracellular glucose levels and seizure
susceptibility in adult rats in vivo. They tested the hypothesis that increased
glucose concentration is proactive in the flurothyl
model of one type of generalized seizures (flurothyl
is a potent gaseous convulsant which is capable of
inducing seizures by inhalation). Hyperglycemia was found to be induced in two
ways: (a) streptozotocin (STZ) administration, which
reliably results in hyperglycemia and results in diabetes; and (b) short-term intraperitoneal injection of 20% glucose to make up a
condition of nonketotic hyperglycemia which is
independent of diabetes. A wide range of well-chosen controls were used to
compare their outcomes. The three groups comprising of “nondiabetic
controls” included rats that are injected with the STZ vehicle, STZ-injected
rats that did not develop diabetes and are resistant to it, and rats that
received no injection but otherwise were handled similarly to the other
animals. A final comparison group consisted of rats that underwent a 24-hour
fast and thus were hypoglycemic.
Testing with flurothyl
indicated a negative correlation between blood glucose level and clonic seizure threshold—with STZ-induced diabetic rats
having significantly marked lower seizure thresholds than did nondiabetic controls. Fasted, hypoglycemic rats had the
highest thresholds, the result shows. To control the other metabolic or
hormonal effects resulting from STZ injection, an additional group of rats was
injected with 20% glucose, 30 minutes before flurothyl
testing, and then the results were compared with saline-injected controls.
Again, the hyperglycemic rats had significantly lower thresholds for clonic flurothyl seizures,
claiming that hyperglycemia itself is found to be proconvulsant,
in both diabetic and normal rats. Furthermore, no damage is seen to hippocampal neurons in any of the experimental conditions,
as assessed by Fluoro-Jade and silver stain
techniques, suggesting that neither STZ or elevated glucose leads to structural
neuronal injury.
Next, Schwechter and their
colleagues evaluated the effects of elevated extracellular glucose on epileptiform activity in vitro. Slices of entorhinal cortex–hippocampus were exposed to a Mg2+-free
extracellular medium, causing epileptiform bursts for
which amplitude and frequency can be measured and compared under different
experimental conditions. In Mg2+-free medium with 10 mM extracellular glucose (i.e., the usual glucose
concentration used in slice experiments), typical epileptiform
discharges occurred. When the glucose was increased to 20 mM,
epileptiform burst frequency did not change; however,
the burst amplitudes increased significantly, showing enhanced neuronal firing.
The effect was reversed when the glucose was again switched back to 10 mM. In addition, no epileptiform
discharges were seen in normal cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), that is 2 mM Mg2+, plus a 20 mM
glucose solution. As a result—consider the fact that nearly all brain-slice
electrophysiology experiments have used a CSF-glucose concentration of 10 mM, rather than the physiologic concentration, which
is closer to 5 mM. The traditionally accepted
practice of using the higher-glucose-level solutions is based on empiric
experience, showing that the synaptic viability of slices is optimized with the
higher concentration. [11]
This well-designed study confirms previous work with
several animal models of diabetes, which show a reduction in seizure threshold.
The important new finding from Schwechter and
colleagues is that hyperglycemia, itself, is proconvulsant.
How can elevated glucose enhance seizure susceptibility? The answer to this
crucial question regarding the mechanism of action awaits further research, as
the mechanism per se is not addressed in this report. However, one clue to the
answer might be gleaned from the author's observation that hypoglycemia was
associated with a higher seizure threshold. Other studies have indicated that
restricting calories, thus inducing hypoglycemia, in the epilepsy-prone EL mouse
also reduces seizure susceptibility. [12] With any model that
induces hypoglycemia, the role of ketosis must be excluded, as ketones themselves can affect seizure threshold. [13]
Moreover, multiple other mechanisms could explain
hypoglycemia- and hyperglycemia-induced alterations of neuronal excitability.
Furthermore, the effects of age on glucose balance and neuronal excitability
must be delineated, as children with diabetes tend to develop seizures with
hypoglycemia rather than with hyperglycemia. In addition to clarifying further
the relation between hyperglycemia and seizures, Schwechter
et al. highlight the link between metabolism and neuronal excitability and
emphasize the need for further research on the long-term effects of
hyperglycemia on various aspects of brain function. [14]
EPILEPSY OR DIABETES- A CONFUSION OR COMMON CURE?
Though it is surprising to hear, but according to
recent research it is confirmed that epilepsy and diabetes are more in common
than we thought. The key feature is fluctuating blood sugar. People with
hyperglycemia are more prone to have focal or local seizures. And those people
who are hypoglycemic, tend to have tonic-clonic
seizures. [15]
Although some patients and even some doctors disagree
with this study, there’s really not much difference between a seizure due to
diabetic and other different forms of seizures, such as those caused by
epilepsy. While the symptoms doesn’t differ- there seem to be one important
significant difference – the blood sugar irregularities which can cause a
diabetic seizures can also cause the diabetic patient to lapse into a coma
sometimes found to be fatal. [16, 17]
One dilemma facing is that both epilepsy has their
common source. If the seizures are caused by blood sugar fluctuations, treatment
with anti-seizures drugs which cause electrical impulses in the brain are
addressing the wrong problems.Yet we all know that
diet plays an important key role in controlling epilepsy.Interestingly
the study reveals, initial testing shows that a diabetes drug widely used to
treat diabetics manages their condition could also become recognised
as an effective and easy way for treating epilepsy. According to reports, Metformin (brand name Glucophage)
could be particularly very useful in treating epilepsy patients who are drug resistant.Glucophage a popular and effective oral drug for
type 2 diabetes, helps lower blood sugar levels by improving the way the body
interacts with insulin. Much like the ketogenic diet
which treats epilepsy by minimising the levels of
dietary starch and sugar.
A team headed up by Dr. Avtar
Roopra reported that glucophage
was able to turn on a molecule that regulates energy, and then found that they
could suppress the extremely active nerve cells by inhibiting the transfer of
sugar into excess energy. The key goal is to reduce the rate of epilepsy but
not enough to affect the brain’s ability to learn and remember. [18, 19,
20]
WHETHER IT IS EPILEPTIC SEIZURE OR DIABETES RELATED
HYPOGLYCEAMIA?
Observation of the pattern, duration and
characteristics of the seizures, an electroencephalogram, and CT scans, helps
doctors in diagnosis. Nocturnal epilepsy increases the difficulty of diagnosis
of epilepsy because of the fact that seizures that usually occur at night are
not witnessed in the day time mostly.Some case
studies referred in the literature show patients who presented with a tonic-clonic seizure associated with hypoglycaemia
were mistakenly diagnosed with epilepsy. If you are in a treatment and taking
medication that causes the pancreas to release more insulin (like Glucotrol, Amaryl, Prandin, Glipizide, etc) or if
you are taking insulin injections it is imperative to discern whether you are
having low glucose levels during the night while sleeping as this could be the
cause of your seizures. A continuous glucose monitoring system which is used to
diagnose diabetes, a pager-sized device typically worn for 2-3 days that
continually measures glucose, can determine if you are going too low and guide
you.
TYPE 1 DIABETES TO INCREASE EPILEPSY RISK THREEFOLD:
Children and adolescents with type 1 diabetes are
nearly 3fold times higher in risk to develop epilepsy than other people without
type 1 diabetes, according to a large insurance claims study from Taiwan.The study findings are similar with other, only
limited research is carried and that suggests a link between type 1 diabetes
and epilepsy, but more research is to be performed in the future to determine
how this occurs, according to I- Ching Chou, MD, from
China Medical University Children’s Hospital, in Taichung, Taiwan, and
colleagues. The researchers reported their results in an article published
online March 31, 2016 in Diabetologia.
The pathogenic mechanisms of neurological diseases
(such as epilepsy) remain unknown but may be associated with significant long
term neurological sequelae, they stress. Thus the
causative agent between type 1 diabetes and the increased risk of epilepsy
require further investigation and keen study, they conclude. [18]
“Teasing out the causes of seizures is tedious to do
retrospectively in an administrative database,” Kenneth Mandl,
MD, MPH, from Harvard Medical School and Boston Children’s Hospital,
Massachusetts, told Medscape Medical News. However as
previously reported his team performed a similar analysis of US insurance
claims data and they conclude that patients who had any of 12 autoimmune
diseases had an increased risk of epilepsy and those with type 1 diabetes had a
5.2 fold increased risk of epilepsy.Dr Mandl agrees that the link between diabetes and epilepsy
risk “should certainly be studied further”, ideally in “populations where
coding can be confirmed with clinical review and characterisation
of the seizures.” [18]
TREATMENT FOR EPILEPSY:
The physician determines the type of seizure and look
forward in a preventative manner, and anti-seizure medication is prescribed
accordingly. This is a origin of frustration for many people who ask, “Why do i need to take this medication if i
am not having seizures?” Antiseizure medication
should be taken regularly for the control of seizure as we take high blood
pressure or diabetes medication even when the numbers are in the ideal range-
to keep the medical condition under control! Plus, there is a higher risk for a
second seizure within 3 years after experiencing the first seizure is about 30%
and the lifetime risk of recurrence is 14-50%. Other factors are important in
the treatment of seizures removing tumors(if that is the cause) and correcting
metabolic disturbances.For people with type 1
diabetes, controlling glucose levels to minimise
their effect which diabetes has on the nervous system. Also the effect of sleep
quality on seizure frequency is well known from the literature. A careful
scrutiny of potential sleep disturbing factors such as primary sleep disorders
is of utmost importance to the successful management of seizures.Whenever
faced with a chronic health condition, like diabetes or epilepsy, it always
helps to speak with the experts and those who experience it firsthand as they
can share clearly. [20]
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: The
authors are thankful to Vels University (VISTAS) and
its management for providing research facilities and encouragement.
REFERENCE:
1.
Chang
BS, Lowenstein DH (2003). "Epilepsy". N. Engl. J. Med. 349 (13): 1257–66.
doi:10.1056/FNEJMra022308.
PMID 14507951.
2.
Fisher,
Robert S; Acevedo, C; Arzimanoglou, A; Bogacz, A; Cross, JH; Elger, CE;
Engel J, Jr; Forsgren, L;
French, JA; Glynn, M; Hesdorffer, DC; Lee, BI; Mathern, GW; Moshé, SL; Perucca, E; Scheffer, IE; Tomson, T; Watanabe, M; Wiebe, S
(April 2014). "ILAE
Official Report: A practical clinical definition of epilepsy"
(PDF). Epilepsia 55 (4): 475–82. doi:10.1111/epi.12550.
PMID 24730690.
3.
"Epilepsy
Fact sheet". WHO. February 2016. Retrieved 4 March 2016.
4.
Fisher
R, van Emde Boas W, Blume
W, Elger C, Genton P, Lee
P, Engel J (2005). "Epileptic seizures and epilepsy: definitions proposed
by the International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) and the International
Bureau for Epilepsy (IBE)". Epilepsia 46 (4):
470–2. doi:10.1111/j.0013-9580.2005.66104.x.
PMID 15816939.
5.
Longo,
Dan L (2012). "369 Seizures and Epilepsy". Harrison's principles of
internal medicine (18th ed.). McGraw-Hill. p. 3258. ISBN 978-0-07-174887-2.
6.
Pandolfo, M. (Nov 2011). "Genetics of epilepsy.". Semin Neurol 31 (5): 506–18. doi:10.1055/s-0031-1299789. PMID 22266888.
7.
National
Clinical Guideline Centre (January 2012). The
Epilepsies: The diagnosis and management of the epilepsies in adults and
children in primary and secondary care (PDF). National Institute for
Health and Clinical Excellence. pp. 21–28.
8.
National
Clinical Guideline Centre (January 2012). The
Epilepsies: The diagnosis and management of the epilepsies in adults and
children in primary and secondary care (PDF). National Institute for
Health and Clinical Excellence. pp. 119–129.
9.
Hammer,
edited by Stephen J. McPhee, Gary D. (2010).
"7". Pathophysiology of disease : an
introduction to clinical medicine (6th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill Medical. ISBN 978-0-07-162167-0.
10. Hughes, JR (August 2009). "Absence
seizures: a review of recent reports with new concepts.” Epilepsy &
behavior : E&B 15 (4): 404–12. doi:10.1016/j.yebeh.2009.06.007.
PMID 19632158.
11. Schwartzkroin PA.. Characteristics of CA1 neurons
recorded intracellularly in the hippocampal
in vitro slice preparation. Brain Res 1975;85: 423–436. [PubMed]
12. Greene AE, Todorova
MT, McGowan R, Seyfried TN.. Caloric restriction
inhibits seizure susceptibility in epileptic EL mice by reducing blood glucose.
Epilepsia 2001;42: 1371–1378. [PubMed]
13. Stafstrom CE.. Effects of fatty acids and ketones on neuronal excitability: implications for epilepsy
and its treatment. In: Mostofsky DI, Yehuda S, Salem N Jr, editors. ,
eds. Fatty acids: physiological and behavioral functions. : Humana Press, 2001:
273–290.
14. Gispen WH, Biessels GJ.. Cognition and synaptic plasticity in diabetes mellitus. Trends Neurosci 2000;23: 542–549. [PubMed
]17.
URL:http://www.diabetes.org/news-research/news/diabetes-in-the-news/combo-pill-an-option.html
19.
Epilepsy and Diabetes – Confusion or Common “Cure”?
URL: http://my.epilepsy.com/blogentry/980548
20.
Pediatrics. 2012 Feb; 129 (2) : e511-4. doi: 10. 1542/peds. 2011-0741. Epub 2012 Jan 16.
Received on 18.09.2016
Modified on 20.10.2016