Benefits of utilizing pictorial-based wellbeing training for asthmatic Patients of low financial income among Tirupur textile Workers:

An Integrative Audit

 

A. Muthukumar¹*, R. Gayathri², Rumana Khatija¹, Sundara Ganapathy. R³, S. Mohan²

¹Department of Pharmacology, Krupanidhi College of Pharmacy,

Varthur Hobli, Off Sarjapur Road, Bangalore-560035

²Department of Pharmaceutics Karpagam College of Pharmacy, Othakkalmandapam, Coimbatore- 641032

³Faculty of Pharmacy, Karpagam Academy of Higher Education, Salem Kochi Highway,

Eachanari, Coimbatore-641021.

 

ABSTRACT:

Objectives: To assess the job of pictograms in passing on data about medication use, diet, and lifestyle alterations for asthma patients and to build up a pictographic handout for advising them. Information also included of patients with essential training determined to have respiratory sicknesses. Methodology: A randomized preliminary was directed with 1346 patients visiting a local chest tertiary hospital in Tiruppur, Tamil Nadu, India from January 2017 to July 2018.Two mediation batches utilizing sets of pictorial marks (one privately created, one non-nearby) were contrasted with a control bunch utilizing the "standard consideration" technique (an arrangement of numbers and dashes set straightforwardly on the asthma medication device) ordinarily utilized by Indian human services suppliers. Appreciation of restoring data (for measurement and medication sign characterized as the issue for which the medication was recommended) and adherence to tranquilize routine were estimated utilizing things from an organized survey directed somewhere in the range of two and seven days after the facility visit. Results: Perception of the measurements did not fluctuate among control and mediation gatherings. The patient gets pictorial hints were altogether bound to comprehend the signs of their needs contrasted with textile workers in the control gathering. Conclusion: In spite of the fact that these information propose locally developed pictograms might be more effectively comprehended than non-nearby pictograms, further inquire about is expected to help these discoveries.

 

 

 

INTRODUCTION:

Wellbeing proficiency is a pivotal factor to think about while talking about appreciation of medication data. Wellbeing education is "how much people have the ability to acquire, process, and comprehend essential wellbeing data and administrations expected to make proper wellbeing decisions¹. Poor wellbeing proficiency is profoundly corresponded with low education (characterized as a poor capacity to peruse and comprehend composed words), in both high and low asset settings².

 

An investigation led with pregnant ladies in Egypt found that low proficiency was related with poor medication comprehension³. Additional examinations directed in the United States have affirmed that low education prompts poor perception of composed restorative directions, for example, data shown on solution names and packaging⁴. Different components have been appeared to be related with low perception of restorative guidelines. For instance, contemplates have discovered that suppliers frequently give confounding or insufficient data amid patient visits, prompting misconception of restorative instructions⁵. Poorcognizance of wellbeing data is related with non-adherence to sedate regimens and other wellbeing instructions⁶. Utilizing pictograms to delineate wellbeing data is certainly not another thought. However, just a bunch of pictorial intercessions have endeavoured to outwardly portray sedate sign. A few examinations have 6 appeared low-proficient populaces, specifically, are better ready to review medical data when it is given in pictorial structure⁷. However, the vast majority of the pictorial intercessions analyzed in these examinations focused on unskilled or low-proficient populaces in high-pay nations. These results are not effectively translatable to networks in low-asset settings⁸. One investigation led in Cameroon found that utilization of pictorial guides expanded comprehension of restoring data in a low-educated populace.

 

MATERIALS AND METHODS:

Pictogram intervention - plan and improvement:

Pictograms for medication sign were planned by four craftsmen. A progression of centre gatherings and individual meetings with nearby ladies and human services suppliers were led to choose the two craftsmen whose pictograms would be fused into the name mediations for this investigation.

Advancement of study device:

An overview device for home line up was structured with the direction of a few asthma patients' wellbeing specialists and general wellbeing scientists. The meeting plan was pilot-tried with a few neigh bour hood before the inquiries were finished, and it contained 20 inquiries to gather itemized statistic data on maternal qualities and family unit size and occupation, care seeking rehearses, appreciation of pictograms utilized on the marks, perception of measurement (number of pills (inhalation) and number of times each day) and sign for each prescription recommended, saw utility of the names, and adherence to medicate routine. The settled review device was then converted into Tamil. Since the nearby language, Tamil, has no composed structure, the surveyors directed the inquiries by on-the-spot interpretation from English to Tamil shown in (figure 1and 2).

 

 

Figure -1 Pictorial in Tamil

 

STATISTICAL ANALYSIS:

Chi-square examination was utilized to test for huge contrasts in the dispersion of statistic, asthmatic, and richness qualities between the control and mediation groups. Multiple calculated relapse was utilized to test for relationship between every one of three outcome variables (adherence, dose perception, and medication sign cognizance) and several predictor factors by each examination gathering. Since the result factors encountered a ceiling effect in which most of perceptions fell in the most noteworthy scoring class, they were dichotomous between "immaculate score" and "not exactly consummate score" for the reasons of 13 regression investigation.

 

RESULTS:

Fifteen thousand patients were enlisted to take an interest in the investigation (Fig. 2). One hundred and fifty four patients (8.97%) declined to take an interest. This was due to reasons such as failure to look for consent from their respective spouses (who were missing on day of hospital visit) and issues with transportation back to their home town. A sum of 1382 asthma patients was doled out to one of the three investigation gatherings. 36 patients were lost to development, bringing about an examination populace of 1346 patients 758 female and 588 male: 91 in the control gathering (graduate), 617 in Intervention bunch 1 (nearby marks), and 638 in Intervention bunch 2 (non-neighbourhood marks). Statistic (P<0.001) and asthmatic /richness qualities of the members are introduced in (Tables 1).

 

Table 1: Education Based Distribution of Study among asthma Participants

Literacy	Female	%	Male	%	Total	%	P Value
Middle School	287	38%	144	24%	431	32%	0.00
HSC	98	13%	88	15%	186	14%
Illiterate	329	43%	309	53%	638	47%
Graduate	44	6%	47	8%	91	7%
Total	758	100%	588	100%	1346	100%

 

 

Figure 2: literacy skill wise distribution

 

With respect to literacy level of the study participants, majority of the population irrespective of the gender were illiterates, amounting to 329 (43%) females and 309 (53%) males; whereas only around 7% of the total study population were graduates. The education based distribution of study participants is shown in (Figure 1).

 

This module is aimed to assess the impact of improved medication adherence in patients with bronchial asthma. During the pre-intervention phases the gender wise distribution of study respondents in three stages of asthma control is depicted in (Table 2).

 

 

Table 2: Gender wise distribution of patients according to asthma control

Gender	No of Respondents	Under Control	Reasonable Control	Poor Control
FEMALE	56.3%	7.9%	13.3%	35.1%
MALE	43.7%	6.5%	10.8%	26.4%
Grand Total	100.0%	14.4%	24.1%	61.5%

 

Appreciation of time-of-day pictograms was high among ladies in both mediation gatherings, with no noteworthy contrast in understanding of each pictogram between inhalation gatherings. Since the equivalent pictograms were utilized for both textile worker gatherings, no distinction in perception between the two gatherings was normal. The pictogram was the most effectively comprehended, 14.4% under control patient’s moves into 79.8% of patients accurately translating it is statistically significant (P<0.05) were shown in (Table-3). Post-intervention study of asthma control occurs after the pharmacist's intervention, the asthma controls have significantly improved in different aspect. The improvement in asthma control based on duration. Pre-intervention study on occupational asthma among textile workers in various department 14.4% of patients having under control, 24.1% of subjects reasonable control and 61.5% of in poor control in respiratory challenges take places in during working hours changes to 8.3% were statistically significance P<0.05) shown in (Table-3). After the pharmacist's intervention using pictogram (Post-intervention study), the asthma controls have significantly improved in different aspect. The improvements in asthma control based on occupational asthma group were shown in (Table 3).

Table 3: Pictorial improvement in Asthma Control Test in different occupational group patients

Occupation	Under Control		Reasonable Control		Poor Control
	Follow Up 1	Follow Up 2	Follow Up 1	Follow Up 1	Follow Up 2	Follow Up 1
Checking	27.0%	30.1%	4.5%	23.2%	7.1%	3.7%
Helpers	36.1%	37.1%	4.6%	33.1%	7.7%	2.5%
Ironing	4.4%	4.0%	0.6%	2.6%	1.5%	0.8%
Overlock	11.4%	9.3%	1.3%	7.2%	3.3%	0.8%
Packing	6.1%	6.1%	1.0%	4.0%	1.2%	0.7%
Patlock	8.8%	8.0%	1.4%	5.8%	1.9%	1.9%
Singer tailor	6.2%	5.5%	1.0%	4.0%	1.5%	1.3%
Grand Total	14.4%	79.8%	24.1%	11.9%	61.5%	8.3%
P Value	0.056		0.036		0.032

 

DISCUSSION:

Pictograms are likewise regular in patient data flyers for restorative items⁹. Pictograms in these flyers are proposed to give full and fathomable data since patients' capacity to comprehend data about medicine is significant to both patient wellbeing and medication adequacy¹⁰. Pictograms are of advantage to the cognizance and review of remedy guidelines, and members who are given "characteristic language in addition to pictogram" names comprehend data superior to members with just "regular language marks" ¹¹. In any case, some exploration has not bolstered the theory that pictograms are useful for the procurement and understanding of data. So as to assess the impacts of pictograms in patient data flyers, Bernardini and his associates met 1004 patients in drug stores and announced that members as a rule read the patient data handout however they neither comprehended it effectively nor found the required data promptly¹². Be that as it may, most members (74.3%) considered the utilization of images accommodating in finding the required data¹³. They dissected to what degree five images could be utilized for every one of five themes, and found reliable reactions for "symptoms"', "paediatric use", "use in pregnancy" and "measurements", however not for "helpful signs" and "contraindications". While evaluating pictogram viability, Wolff and Wogalter et al suggest displaying the pictogram in the earth in which it will in the end be seen¹⁴. This condition frames some portion of the unique situation, the job needing to be done being another part¹⁵. Setting is a help for translating a pictogram's significance. Setting diminishes a pictogram's polysemy¹⁶. Studies have exhibited that expanding the dimension of relevant data will in general wipe out a specific number of mistakes, for example, those because of enacting run of the mill compositions, or choosing the wrong capacity, or when there is a misconception regarding what is really spoken to in the pictogram¹⁷. For example, when a pictogram on sun cream bundling demonstrating a sun with a cross on it is translated as ''don't leave the sun cream in the sun'', while the right significance is ''when cream connected, don't open skin to the sun''. Setting disambiguates the message communicated in the pictogram¹⁸. Suggestions additionally have been made with respect to learning¹⁹. Pictograms which are not quickly perceived might be adapted quickly, after which the job of the pictogram is to animate review of that data²⁰. Therefore a definitive achievement of a pictogram would rely upon students' capacity to learn it cautiously²¹. One proposal for ideal learning is to utilize scientific categorizations to empower students to separate among pictograms, and to utilize pulmonologist with the end goal for learners to separate between the implications of pictogram segments²². Every one of these suggestions can be accomplished through the coordinated effort of part pros, creators, and therapists^23-24.

 

CONCLUSION:

While surveying pictogram adequacy, researchers suggest introducing the pictogram in the earth in which it will in the end be seen. This condition frames some portion of the unique circumstance, the job needing to be another part. The setting is a support for translating a pictogram's importance. Setting lessens a pictogram's polysemy. Studies have shown that expanding the dimension of relevant data tends to wipe out a specific number of blunders, for example, thus because of initiating common constructions, or choosing the wrong capacity, or when there is a misreading concerning what is really spoken to in the pictogram. For example, when a pictogram on sun cream bundling demonstrating a sun with a cross on it is translated as ''don't leave the sun cream in the sun'', while the right significance is ''when cream connected, don't open skin to the sun''. Setting disambiguates the message communicated in the pictogram. Suggestions additionally have been made with respect to learning. Pictograms which are definitely not quickly apparent might be adapted quickly, after which the job of the pictogram is to animate review of that data. In this way a definitive achievement of a pictogram would depend on students' capacity to learn it cautiously. One suggestion for ideal learning is to utilize scientific classifications to empower learners to separate among pictograms, and to utilize ontologies in request for students to separate between the implications of pictogram parts.

 

CONFLICT OF INTEREST:

The author declares there is no conflict of interest.

 

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS:

We take this opportunity to express our gratitude and respectful thanks to Dr. R. Vasantha Kumar, Chairman Karpagam Group of Educational Institutions Coimbatore. I would like extend my respectful thanks to Dr. M. Ramanathan, Principal, PSG College of Pharmacy, and Coimbatore.

 

REFERENCES:

1.      Mansoor, L. E., and Dowse, R. Effect of pictograms on readability of patient information materials. The Annals of Pharmacotherapy. 2003: 37(7-8); 1003-1009.

2.      Naveen MR, Santhosh YL. Asthma: An Overview. Research J. Pharm. and Tech. 4(6): June 2011; Page 883-890.

3.      P. Maheshwari, I. Somasundaram. Health Related Quality of Life Measurement in Asthma and Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease. Research J. Pharm. and Tech. 2016; 9(5): 518-520.

4.      Davis, T. C., Wolf, M. S., Bass, P. F.,3rd, Thompson, J. A., Tilson, H. H., Neuberger, M.. Literacy and misunderstanding prescription drug labels. Annals of Internal Medicine 2006:145(12); 887-894.

5.      Dowse, R., and Ehlers, M. S. The evaluation of pharmaceutical pictograms in a low-literate South African population. Patient Education and Counseling. 2001:45(2); 87-99.

6.      Houts, P. S., Witmer, J. T., Egeth, H. E., Loscalzo, M. J., and Zabora, J. R. Using pictographs to enhance recall of spoken medical instructions II. Patient Education and Counseling.2001: 43(3); 231- 242.

7.      Katz, M. G., Kripalani, S., and Weiss, B. D. Use of pictorial aids in medication instructions: A review of the literature. American Journal of Health-System Pharmacy : AJHP : Official Journal of the American Society of Health-System Pharmacists.2006: 63(23); 2391-2397.

8.      O'Brien, M. K., Petrie, K., and Raeburn, J. Adherence to medication regimens: Updating a complex medical issue. Medical Care Review.1992: 49(4); 435-454.

9.      Ponnusankar, S., Surulivelrajan, M., Anandamoorthy, N., and Suresh, B. Assessment of impact of medication counseling on patients' medication knowledge and compliance in an outpatient clinic in south India. Patient Education and Counseling.2004:54(1); 55-60.

10.   Dowse, R., and Ehlers, M.S. Pictograms in pharmacy. The International Journal of Pharmacy Practice.1998: 6; 109- 118.

11.   Bernardini, C., Ambrogi, V., Peroli, L.C., Tiraltri, M., and Fardella, G. Comprehensibility of the package leaflets of all medicinal products for human use: a questionnaire survey about the use of symbols and pictograms. Pharmacological Research.2000: 41 (6);679-688.

12.   Wolff, J.S. and Wogalter, M. S. Comprehension of Pictorial Symbols: Effects of Context and Test Method. Human Factors.1998: 40, (2); 173-186.

13.   Santa, J.L. Spatial transformation of words and pictures. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory.1977: 3; 418-427.

14.   Thanaa Abdulmahdi Mokif, Alaa Jawad Hassan, Zainab Nasser Nabat. Evaluation of some Physiological Parameters in patients with Asthma. Research J. Pharm. and Tech. 2019; 12(5):2425-2429.

15.   Knapp P, Raynor DK, Jebar AH, and Price SJ. Interpretation of medication pictograms by adults in the UK. The Annals of Pharmacotherapy. 2005: 39; 1227-1233.

16.   Kolers, P.A. Some formal characteristics of pictograms. American Scientist. 1969: 57; 348-363.

17.   Arend, U., Muthig, K.-P., and Wandmacher, J. Evidence for global feature superiority in menu selection by icons. Behavior and Information Technology. 1987: 6; 411–426.

18.   Barcenilla, J., and Tijus, C. Compréhension et Evaluation et de Pictogrammes: Effets du Contexte. Psychologie Française. 2002: 47(1); 55-64.

19.   Muthu Kumar A., Gayathri R., Keserla Bhavani, Rumana Khatija, Sundara Ganapathy R.. Clinical Assessment on Knowledge of Garments Dust Induced Bronchial Asthma among Kongu Nadu Textile Workers. Research J. Pharm. and Tech. 2019; 12(6): 2721-2723.

20.   Roberts, N. J., Mohamed, Z., Wong, P. S., Johnson, M., Loh, L. C., and Partridge, M. R. The development and comprehensibility of a pictorial asthma action plan. Patient Education and Counseling.2009:74(1); 12-18.

21.   Bestley Joe S, Gomathi T, Maflin Shaby S, Pandian R. Self-Assistance Devices for Asthma Patients using Android Application Research J. Pharm. and Tech 2018; 11(5):1945-1950.

22.   Lingaraju.CM, Santosh Kumar SK, Munirathnamma. A Study to assess the knowledge on prevention of asthma among farmers in selected settings Mysuru. Int. J. Adv. Nur. Management. 2016; 4(4): 404-406.

23.   Bharti Ahirwar, Alpana Ram, Dheeraj Ahirwar. Air Pollution: A Major Culprit of Asthma. Research J. Science and Tech. 2009; 1(1): 1-3.

24.   Santosh Nadig, R. Rajeshwari. Effectiveness of Structured Teaching Programme on Knowledge and Techniques Regarding Metered Dose Inhalers (MDI) among Bronchial Asthma Patients in Selected Hospitals of Mangalore Taluk. Int. J. Adv. Nur. Management. 2016; 4(3): 223-234.

 

 

Received on 25.09.2019           Modified on 19.10.2019

Accepted on 26.11.2019         © RJPT All right reserved