Factors Shaping Consumer Trust in the Remote Purchase of Over-the-Counter Medicines
D.V. Babaskin*, L.A. Adzieva, T.M. Litvinova, L.I. Babaskina, I.U. Glazkova, О.V. Savinova
I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University (Sechenov University),
8-2 Trubetskaya str., Moscow, 119991, Russia.
*Corresponding Author E-mail: babaskin.d.v@mail.ru
ABSTRACT:
To solve the urgent task of optimizing pharmaceutical activities in the remote sale of over-the-counter medicines, it is necessary to study the factors that form consumer trust in this type of trade. The aim is to identify factors that have a positive impact on the formation of consumer trust in the remote purchase of over-the-counter medicines and conduct a marketing study on them in a group of target consumers in Russia. Materials and methods. The objects of the marketing study were 32 established formative factors. A survey of 629 target consumers from 18 regions of the European part of Russia was conducted. Field research was conducted using an oral survey (21.5%) and a web survey (78.5%), using a structured questionnaire. Results and discussion. 24 hypotheses were formulated, and 32 factors were identified that had a positive impact on the formation of consumer trust in the remote purchase of over-the-counter medicines. The marketing analysis showed a fairly high significance (importance) of the studied factors. The significant predominance of positive ratings in the overall frequency ratio (83.3±9.2%) and their prevalence among minimally important factors (about 70%) confirmed the correctness of the developed hypotheses and the possibility of using factors to build consumer trust in the remote purchase of over-the-counter medicines. The presence of an average positive effect from the practical impact of the proposed factors on Russian consumers was empirically proven (the combined parametric index is 4.3). A reliable dependence of the formation of some trust factors on the age group of respondents was established. Conclusions. There is a need for further research to understand the mechanism of behavioral intention underlying the formation of consumer trust concerning the remote purchase of over-the-counter medicines.
KEYWORDS: Remote purchase, Consumer trust, Trust factors, Building trust, Marketing.
INTRODUCTION:
Currently, the remote retail sale of over-the-counter (OTC) medicines occupies a major share of the global e-pharmacy market and is a legal and generally accepted practice in most countries1-4. The compound annual growth rate (CAGR 2024-2029) is expected to be 9.63%, as a result of which the projected volume of this market by 2029 will be $ 130.50 billion5.
The advantages of online purchases of medicines are saving time and money, favorable prices, the convenience of searching and comparing products, a large assortment (selection) of goods, the ability to find the right products and compare prices, offers, and discounts, the ability to shop anytime and anywhere, completeness of information and the ability to make the right choice, door to door delivery, and lack of personal communication with people in difficult epidemic situations3,6-9. A study by the analytical company RNC Pharma well-known in the field of marketing information in the Russian pharmaceutical market, showed that the total volume of online sales in the first quarter of 2024 amounted to 103.1 billion rubles, which is 28.6% more than the same period last year, and exceeded the increase in sales in the pharmaceutical retail market (19.8%, including parapharmaceutical products)10.Although the popularity of remote purchases of medicines is steadily growing, consumers are faced with a new online payment environment, huge amounts of information, and problems with online access to trained specialists, with higher risks that may be exacerbated by the presence of illegal websites, substandard and falsified medicines, difficulties in managing personal information, and other circumstances1,11-14. This is reflected in their trust in these purchases, which is currently a key condition for the further development of e-retailing of OTC medicines1,11,13. The need to study trust is also explained:
1) By an increase in transaction costs with a low level of trust and irrational use of resources15,
2) By the many benefits for online buyers (consumers of OTC medicines) and sellers (pharmacy organizations): increasing the level of consumer satisfaction, their trust in the security of personal data16, and the perceived level of safety of purchasing OTC medicines by consumers1,15, a more positive perception of medicine manufacturers17, etc.,
3) By the possibility of increasing the overall level of trust in society18,19,
4) By the direct impact on the adoption of new technologies20 and the development of the digital economy21.
There are various approaches to building consumer trust. In our opinion, the well-established unified theory of acceptance and use of technology (UTAUT) and its extended UTAUT2 model, which reveal behavioral aspects of consumer trust, including electronic retail of goods, are more suitable for this purpose concerning the online purchase of OTC medicines. However, this theory does not consider the influence of government policy in the field of consumer protection on the development of trust, the role of information quality in online medicine purchases, the quality of service, the possibility of transforming pharmacy into digital form and acquiring special importance of digital trust factors, and the urgent demand of OTC medicine consumers for online consultations. Therefore, it is of particular relevance:
1) To establish the possibility of using the behavioral factors UTAUT and UTAUT2 to form trust in the online purchase of OTC medicines,
2) To introduce other trust factors positively correlating with the formation of the trust under study,
3) To perform a marketing analysis of the combined formative factors of the trust under study.
This will optimize pharmaceutical activities in remote retail sales of medicines and shift the vector of the studied consumer trust to increase the perceived benefit of the purchase and reduce the perceived risk and uncertainty.
The work aims to identify factors that have a positive impact on the formation of consumer trust in the remote purchase of OTC medicines and to conduct marketing research in a group of target consumers in Russia.
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
The methodological basis for establishing the factors that form consumer trust in the online purchase of OTC medicines was based on the conceptual provisions and principles of the methodology of marketing research, the UTAUT and its extended model (UTAUT2), information quality theory, the theory of trust transfer, the theory of digital trust, and the quality of service model (SERVQUAL) adapted to electronic services.
The objects of the marketing study were 32 established formative factors. A survey of target consumers of OTC medicines sold remotely from 18 regions of the European part of Russia was conducted. The criteria for inclusion in the study were real and potential online users of OTC medicines over the age of 18 who agreed to participate in the survey. Participation was anonymous and voluntary, and the respondents were fully aware of the survey's purpose, nature, potential benefits, and risks. The study was based on the principles stipulated by the Helsinki Declaration and the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC)/European Society for Opinion and Marketing Research (ESOMAR) International Code on Market issues, public opinion, social research, and data analysis. The sampling was carried out by a random simple method. The representativeness of the sample was ensured by a sufficient number of respondents (confidence level: 95%, tolerable error: ±5%) and the correspondence of their ratio to the consumer structure of the online pharmaceutical market in Russia9, 13.
Among the 629 respondents, there were 392 women (62.3%) and 237 men (37.7%). Their average age equaled 44.2±10.5 years (median 44, interquartile range (IQR): 34-54). The survey participants were classified into age groups: the participants aged 18-35 were considered young (32.3%); the participants aged 35-55 years – middle-aged (42.6%), and the participants aged 55 and older – elderly (25.1%). According to social status, most respondents were employed (66.5%), and pensioners made up only 11.3%. Most online consumers of OTC medicines had higher professional education (66.6%). The share of respondents with secondary professional education was 20.7%, and the share of the participants without professional education equaled 12.7%. In terms of the average monthly income per family member, most survey participants had an average (58.2%) and low (25.1%) income level.
The field stage of the study was conducted in April-July 2024 using a personal oral survey (21.5%) and a web survey (78.5%) using a structured questionnaire. The questions of the first part of the questionnaire concerned the characteristics of the survey participants, the second part involved the factors that have a positive impact on the formation of respondents' trust in the remote purchase of OTC medicines. All questionnaires were encoded for tracking purposes, and the codes were securely stored.
For marketing analysis of the positive significance (importance) of factors, the Likert scale was used (extremely important, very important, moderately important, slightly important, not at all important). The frequency analysis of the evaluation results was carried out for each factor. The group of positive ratings included the ratings "extremely important" and "very important" according to the Likert scale, the group of neutral ratings included "moderately important", and the group of negative ratings included "slightly important" and "not at all important". The assessment of the level of positive effect from the influence of the studied factors on the respondents was carried out by the method of individual point estimates (according to a 5-point scale), followed by the calculation of integral indicators.
Statistical data processing was performed using the IBM SPSS Statistics 29.0.1 software. The average frequency of occurrence of positively significant assessments (Eav) and the average assessment of the effectiveness of the impact of factors (Aiav) are presented as M±σ (M is the arithmetic mean, σ is the standard quadratic deviation). The critical level of significance in testing statistical hypotheses in the study was assumed to be 0.05.
RESULTS:
Formulation of hypotheses and establishment of factors (derived hypotheses)
To identify the factors that have a positive impact on the formation of consumer trust in the online purchase of OTC medicines, hypotheses were formulated based on the UTAUT and its extended model (UTAUT2), information quality theory, trust transfer theory, digital trust theory, and service quality model (SERVQUAL) adapted to electronic services (Table 1).
Table 1. Factors that have a positive impact on the formation of consumer trust in the remote purchase of OTC medicines
|
Theoretical background |
Hypothesis |
Factor (a derivative of the hypothesis), F |
|
According to the UTAUT, the level of behavioral trust of online shoppers is influenced, among other things, by expected performance, expected effort, social influence, and facilitating conditions |
Expected efficiency (performance) positively correlates with trust in the purchase |
F1. The expected improvement or preservation of health when using OTC medicines purchased remotely |
|
The expected effort positively correlates with trust in the purchase |
F2. The expected ease in making online purchases of OTC medicines |
|
|
F3. Expected availability when making online purchases of OTC medicines |
||
|
F4. The expected convenience when making online purchases of OTC medicines |
||
|
Social influence positively correlates with trust in the purchase |
F5. Positive recommendations from family members on online purchase of OTC medicines |
|
|
F6. Positive recommendations from colleagues and friends on online purchase of OTC medicines |
||
|
Facilitating conditions positively correlate with trust in the purchase |
F7. Having the necessary knowledge to make online purchases of OTC medicines |
|
|
F8. Availability of necessary resources for online purchase of OTC medicines |
||
|
F9. Availability of the necessary support for the online purchase of OTC medicines |
||
|
According to the extended model of the UTAUT (UTAUT2), the level of behavioral trust of online buyers in addition to UTAUT is influenced by habit, hedonistic motivation, and value |
The habit positively correlates with trust in the purchase |
F10.Frequent online purchases of other goods (not medicines) |
|
Hedonistic motivation positively correlates with trust in the purchase |
F11. The pleasure derived from satisfying the need for OTC medicines |
|
|
Value positively correlates with trust in the purchase |
F12. The predominance of the supposed advantages (benefits) from the online purchase of OTC medicines over their monetary cost |
|
|
F13. Estimated lower prices for OTC medicines when buying online |
||
|
Government policy in the field of consumer protection affects the level of their trust |
Ensuring compliance with consumers' rights to access safe goods positively correlates to trust in their purchase |
F14. Ensuring compliance with consumers' rights to access safe OTC medicines when buying online |
|
Protecting the interests of consumers while providing them with equal access to goods positively correlates with trust in their purchase |
F15. Protecting the interests of consumers who make online purchases and ensuring equal access to OTC medicines |
|
|
According to the theory of information quality, the level of trust of online buyers is influenced by the usefulness, sufficiency, and reliability of information about goods |
The usefulness of information about goods positively correlates with trust in their purchase |
|
|
The sufficiency of information about goods positively correlates with the trust in their purchase |
F17. Sufficiency of the information provided on the website by the pharmacy organization for online purchase of OTC medicines |
|
|
The reliability of information about goods positively correlates with the trust in their purchase |
F18. The reliability of the information provided on the website by the pharmacy organization for online purchase of OTC medicines |
|
|
According to the theory of information quality, the level of trust of online buyers is influenced by the feedback mechanism, which allows one to obtain relevant, relevant, accurate, and comprehensive information |
The presence of a feedback mechanism that provides relevant information positively correlates with trust in the online purchase |
F19. Availability of a feedback mechanism that allows one to obtain relevant information for online purchase of OTC medicines |
|
The availability of a feedback mechanism that provides up-to-date information positively correlates with trust in the online purchase |
F20. Availability of a feedback mechanism that allows one to get up-to-date information for online purchase of OTC medicines |
|
|
The availability of a feedback mechanism that provides accurate information positively correlates with trust in the online purchase |
F21. Availability of a feedback mechanism that allows one to get accurate information for online purchase of OTC medicines |
|
|
The availability of a feedback mechanism that provides comprehensive information positively correlates with trust in the online purchase |
F22. Availability of a feedback mechanism that allows one to obtain comprehensive information for online purchase of OTC medicines |
|
|
According to the recommendations on interpersonal communication, the level of trust of online consumers is influenced by online consultations with specialists as more reliable sources of information compared to other sources |
Interpersonal recommendations positively correlate with trust in the purchase |
F23. Online consultations (recommendations) with a doctor before buying OTC medicines |
|
F24. Online consultations (recommendations) with a pharmaceutical worker before buying OTC medicines |
||
|
According to the theory of trust transfer, the cross-channel transfer of trust in various contexts affects the level of trust of online buyers |
The transfer of positive trust from offline purchases of goods to online purchases positively correlates with trust in the online purchase |
F25. Transferring positive trust from offline purchases in certain pharmacy organizations to online purchases |
|
F26. Transferring positive trust from offline purchases of certain medicines to their online purchases |
||
|
According to the theory of digital trust, the level of trust of online consumers is influenced, among other things, by safety and reliability |
The presence of a mechanism that ensures the safety of consumers positively correlates with trust in their online purchase |
F27. The availability of a mechanism that provides online guarantees for security and confidentiality and includes warning information and reliable security signals |
|
The presence of a mechanism that ensures the reliability of the online service positively correlates with the trust in their online purchase |
F28. The availability of a mechanism that ensures the technical and technological reliability of the online service when purchasing OTC medicines |
|
|
According to the service quality model (SERVPERF) adapted to electronic services, the level of trust of online buyers is influenced, among other things, by material values, reliability, responsiveness, confidence |
Perceived material values leading to satisfaction of the need for the product positively correlate with trust in the online purchase |
F29. Perceived good quality of the pharmacy organization's website (attractive design, easy navigation, high-quality content, technical reliability, ease of use, accessibility to search engines) |
|
Perceived reliability in service positively correlates with trust in the online purchase |
F30. Perceived reliability in the timely and accurate delivery of OTC medicines, in the absence of errors and inaccuracies in orders |
|
|
Perceived responsiveness positively correlates with trust in the online purchase |
F31. Perceived responsiveness of pharmacy staff, quick response to requests related to online purchase of OTC medicines |
|
|
Perceived trust in good quality of service positively correlates with trust in the online purchase |
F32. Perceived confidence in the correspondence of the actual quality of service received for the online purchase of OTC medicines to the expected one, or receiving better service than expected |
Based on sources22-29
Marketing analysis of the significance (importance) of factors:
To confirm hypotheses about the positive influence of established factors (derived hypotheses) on the formation of consumer trust in the online purchase of OTC medicines, a marketing analysis of their positive significance in the group of target consumers (respondents) was conducted. We found that the overall frequency ratio of respondents' ratings corresponded (in absolute value) to 524:75:30. The least important factor, "The presence of a feedback mechanism that allows obtaining comprehensive information for online purchase of OTC medicines" (F22) had the ratings of 434:132:63. The average frequency of positive evaluations (Eav) was 83.3±9.2%. The significant predominance of positive ratings in the overall frequency ratio and their prevalence among minimally important factors (about 70%) confirmed the correctness of the developed hypotheses about the positive nature of the established factors and the possibility of using these factors to build consumer trust in the online purchase of OTC medicines. The "not at all important" answer was absent in this study.
The most important factors that had a positive impact on the formation of trust among the survey participants were the following ones: "The expected improvement or preservation of health when using OTC medicines purchased remotely" (F1, E=98.7%) from the UTAUT group of factors; "Ensuring compliance with consumer rights to access safe OTC medicines when buying online" (F14, E=97.0%) and "Protecting the interests of consumers who make online purchases and ensuring equal access to OTC medicines" (F15, E=96.3%) from the group of factors related to government policy; and "Availability of necessary resources for online purchase of OTC medicines" (F8, E=95.1%); "Online consultations (recommendations) of a doctor before buying OTC medicines" (F23, E=94.4%) and "Online consultations (recommendations) of a pharmaceutical worker before buying OTC medicines" (F24, E=94.0%) from the group of interpersonal recommendation factors (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Positioning map of the importance of factors that have a positive impact on the formation of consumer trust in the remote purchase of OTC medicines in Russia (quantitative method, the x-axis shows the factors; the y-axis shows the frequency of positive ratings, E, %)
Marketing analysis of the effectiveness of factors:
To establish the practical influence of factors on the formation of consumer trust in the online purchase of OTC medicines, a marketing analysis of the positive effect of these factors on respondents in Russia was conducted. The survey results showed that the factors with the most pronounced positive effect were "The transfer of positive trust from offline purchases of certain medicines to their online purchases" (F26, Aiav =4.85±0.46), "The expected improvement or preservation of health when using OTC medicines purchased remotely" (F1, Aiav =4.72±0.48), and "The usefulness of the information provided on the pharmacy organization's website for online purchase of OTC medicines" (F16, Aiav=4.62±0.50). The factors "Estimated lower prices for OTC medicines when buying online" (F13) and "Perceived responsiveness of pharmacy employees, quick response to requests related to online purchase of OTC medicines" (F31) were especially pronounced in the age group of older people (p<0.05), and the factor "Frequent online purchases of other goods (not medicines)" (F10) was more common in the group of young people (p<0.05). The overall level of positive effect of the factors on the survey participants was low (Pn=4.3). Especially noteworthy are the low scores on the level of positive effect in the group of highly significant factors of interpersonal recommendations: F23: Aiav =3.86±0.55 and F24: Aiav =3.30±0.68. This can be explained by the insufficiently high prevalence of online consultations with doctors and pharmaceutical workers before the sale of OTC medicines in Russia27, 30.
Table 2. Results of the assessment of the level of positive effect from the impact of factors forming consumer trust in the remote purchase of OTC medicines in Russia
|
Factor |
Rank (Ri)*1 |
Rank value (C)*2 |
Factor weight (Wi)*3 |
Factor assessment (Aiср) |
Parametric index (Pi)*4 |
Summary parametric index (Pn)*5 |
|
F1 |
32 |
0.0019 |
0.061 |
4.72±0.48 |
0.29 |
4.3 |
|
F2 |
7 |
0.013 |
4.35±0.63 |
0.06 |
||
|
F3 |
22 |
0.042 |
4.56±0.55 |
0.20 |
||
|
F4 |
18 |
0.034 |
4.52±0.70 |
0.15 |
||
|
F5 |
12 |
0.023 |
4.26±0.76 |
0.10 |
||
|
F6 |
5 |
0.009 |
4.05±0.60 |
0.04 |
||
|
F7 |
13 |
0.025 |
4.25±0.52 |
0.11 |
||
|
F8 |
29 |
0.055 |
4.23±0.60 |
0.23 |
||
|
F9 |
20 |
0.038 |
4.03±0.52 |
0.15 |
||
|
F10 |
8 |
0.015 |
4.40±0.46 |
0.07 |
||
|
F11 |
19 |
0.036 |
4.05±0.76 |
0.15 |
||
|
F12 |
26 |
0.050 |
4.35±0.48 |
0.22 |
||
|
F13 |
10 |
0.019 |
3.90±0.66 |
0.07 |
||
|
F14 |
31 |
0.059 |
4.20±0.74 |
0.25 |
||
|
F15 |
30 |
0.057 |
4.18±0.65 |
0.24 |
||
|
F16 |
15 |
0.028 |
4.62±0.50 |
0.13 |
||
|
F17 |
14 |
0.027 |
4.25±0.66 |
0.12 |
||
|
F18 |
17 |
0.032 |
4.55±0.74 |
0.15 |
||
|
F19 |
11 |
0.021 |
4.40±0.55 |
0.09 |
||
|
F20 |
3 |
0.006 |
4.25±0.63 |
0.03 |
||
|
F21 |
2 |
0.004 |
4.05±0.74 |
0.02 |
||
|
F22 |
1 |
0.002 |
3.95±0.70 |
0.01 |
||
|
F23 |
28 |
0.053 |
3.86±0.55 |
0.21 |
||
|
F24 |
27 |
0.051 |
0.17 |
|||
|
F25 |
4 |
0.008 |
3.85±0.55 |
0.03 |
||
|
F26 |
23 |
0.044 |
4.85±0.46 |
0.21 |
||
|
F27 |
24 |
0.046 |
4.12±0.70 |
0.19 |
||
|
F28 |
16 |
0.030 |
4.25±0.68 |
0.13 |
||
|
F29 |
6 |
0.011 |
4.35±0.55 |
0.05 |
||
|
F30 |
21 |
0.040 |
4.30±0.74 |
0.17 |
||
|
F31 |
9 |
0.017 |
4.18±0.74 |
0.07 |
||
|
F32 |
25 |
0.047 |
4.30±0.55 |
0.20 |
*1 Direct ranking method. *2 С=1/∑Ri. *3 Wi=Ri • C. *4 Pi=Ai • Wi. *5 Рn=ΣPi.
DISCUSSION:
The choice of UTAUT and its extended model (UTAUT2) showed that the hypotheses formulated on their basis and the established factors (F1-F9 and F1-F13, respectively) had a fairly high significance (Eav=84.4±9.2% and Eav=83.7±8.8%, respectively). The addition of UTAUT theory with UTAUT2 factors (F10-F13) did not significantly reduce the overall average significance of the factors (Eav=82.2±8.9%, p>0.05). Therefore, it is advisable to use the factors of the extended UTAUT2 model to build consumer trust in the remote purchase of OTC medicines. This is consistent with the literature data on using UTAUT2 factors in healthcare31-35. However, in recent years, works have appeared in the literature indicating the controversial nature of certain UTAUT2 trust factors (F2-F4, F7-F9, F12) concerning medical services36-39. These statements make it necessary to conduct further research to understand the mechanism of behavioral intention underlying the formation of consumer trust concerning the online purchase of OTC medicines.
The permissibility of using other trust factors was justified by their essential importance for target consumers. This applied to factors related to the government policy (F14-F15): Eav=96.7±5.0, factors based on information quality theory (F16-F22): Eav=76.5±6.7, factors conditioned by interpersonal recommendations (F23-F24): Eav=94.2±2.8, factors based on the theory of trust transfer (F25-F26): Eav=80.9±13.8, and the theory of digital trust (F27-F28): Eav=87.2±5.9, factors based on the SERVPERF adapted to electronic services (F29-F32): Eav=81.9±9.6. The results obtained for most of these factors (F14, F16-F20, F24, F28-F30) corresponded to the information in the literature concerning pharmacy3, 11, 17, 40-44, medicine26, 45-50, electronic commerce14, 51, but for some of them (F23, F24, F27, F31) there were some discrepancies1, 3, 39, 50. This confirmed the need for further study of the mechanism of formation of consumer trust in the remote purchase of OTC medicines.
A marketing analysis of the positive effect of the impact of factors forming consumer trust showed that only 18.8% of the factors had a high effect (Aiav> 4.5). On the other hand, only 15.6% of the factors had a low positive effect (Aiav< 4.0). The average overall positive effect from the impact of factors on the survey participants (Pn=4.3) indicated the need for an in-depth analysis of the mechanism of practical manifestation of trust factors depending on the demographic characteristics of consumers, the general level of the government legislative framework in the field of circulation of medicines, including the possibility of their remote sale, technical and technological capabilities, the degree of uncertainty and risks for consumers when buying OTC medicines online, as indicated by the authors of some research articles37, 41, 46, 47. In this study, only a reliable influence of the demographic parameter, the age group, on the positive effectiveness of certain factors of respondents' trust was established 52-54.
CONCLUSIONS:
1. Based on the UTAUT2 model, the SERVQUAL service quality model adapted to electronic services, the theory of digital trust, the theory of trust transfer, the theory of information quality, and following the government policy in the field of consumer protection and recommendations on interpersonal communication, 24 hypotheses were formulated and 32 factors were identified that had a positive effect on the formation of consumer trust in the remote purchase of OTC medicines.
2. The marketing analysis showed a fairly high significance (importance) of the studied trust factors among the survey participants. The significant predominance of positive ratings in the overall frequency ratio (83.3±9.2%) and their prevalence in minimally important factors (F21 and F22, about 70%) confirmed the correctness of the developed hypotheses concerning the positive nature of the factors and the possibility of using these factors to build consumer trust in the online purchase of OTC medicines.
3. The presence of an average level of positive effect from the practical impact of the proposed factors on Russian consumers was empirically proven (Pn=4.3). A reliable dependence of the formation of some trust factors (F10, F13, F31) on the age group of respondents was established.
The results showed the need for further research to understand the mechanism of behavioral intention underlying the formation of consumer trust concerning the remote purchase of OTC medicines.
REFERENCES:
1. Fittler A, Ambrus T, Serefko A, Smejkalova L, Kijewska A, Szopa A, Kaplar M. Attitudes and behaviors regarding online pharmacies in the aftermath of COVID-19 pandemic: at the tipping point towards the new normal. Frontiers in Pharmacology. 2022 Dec 23; 13:1070473. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2022.1070473
2. E-Pharmacy market - by product (OTC products, prescription medicine), by region, growth potential, competitive market share and global forecast, 2023-2032. Global Market Insights. 2023. Available at: https://www.gminsights.com/industry-analysis/e-pharmacy-market (accessed on August 28, 2024).
3. Limbu YB, Huhmann BA. What influences consumers' online medication purchase intentions and behavior? A scoping review. Frontiers in Pharmacology. 2024; Feb 13; 15: 1356059. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2024.1356059
4. Lоpez Vila ED, Buts C, Jegers M. A quantitative classification of OTC medicines regulations in 30 European countries: dispensing restrictions, distribution, pharmacy ownership, and pricing systems. Journal of Pharmaceutical Policy and Practice. 2023; 16(1): 19. doi: 10.1186/s40545-023-00522-7
5. Online Pharmacy – Worldwide. Statista. Available at: https://www.statista.com/outlook/hmo/digital-health/digital-treatment-care/digital-care-management/online-pharmacy/worldwide (accessed on August 28, 2024).
6. Almohammed OA, Alnogaidan RA, Ghannam FO, Alqahtani RS, Aloraini SK, Abanmy NO. Public awareness of online pharmacies, consumers' motivating factors, experience and satisfaction with online pharmacy services, and current barriers and motivators for non-consumers: the case of Saudi Arabia. Saudi Pharmaceutical Journal. 2023 Aug; 31(8):101676. doi: 10.1016/j.jsps.2023.06.009
7. Almomani H, Raza A, Patel N, Donyai P. Reasons that lead people to buy prescription medicines on the internet: a systematic review. Frontiers in Pharmacology. 2023 Aug 31; 14:1239507. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2023.1239507
8. Fittler A., Vida R.G., Kaplar M., Botz L. Consumers turning to the Internet pharmacy market: cross-sectional study on the frequency and attitudes of Hungarian patients purchasing medications online. Journal of Medical Internet Research. 2018 Aug 22; 20(8):e11115. doi: 10.2196/11115
9. Lobuteva L, Lobuteva A, Zakharova O, Kartashova O, Kocheva N. The modern Russian pharmaceutical market: consumer attitudes towards distance retailing of medicines. BMC Health Services Research. 2022; Apr 30; 22(1): 582. doi: 10.1186/s12913-022-07991-7
10. Koblova D. RNC Pharma predstavila reiting aptechnykh setei po dole prodazh cherez sobstvennye onlain-servisy [RNC Pharma has presented a rating of pharmacy chains by the share of sales through their own online services]. Farmatsevticheskiy vestnik. June 10, 2024. Available at: https://pharmvestnik.ru/content/news/Summarnaya-dolya-onlain-kanala-rossiiskoi-farmroznicy-za-polgoda-vyrosla-vdvoe.html?ysclid=lzjerf0k3k599020786 (accessed on August 28, 2024).
11. Ersoz S, Nissen A, Schutte R. Risk, trust, and emotion in online pharmacy medication purchases: multimethod approach incorporating customer self-reports, facial expressions, and neural activation. JMIR Formative Research. 2023 Dec 25; 7:e48850. doi: 10.2196/48850
12. Hu Q, Hu H, Hu M, Zhang J, Gou L, Shi S, Zhou J, Zhou N, Huang Z. Use of failure mode and effect analysis to reduce patient safety risks in purchasing prescription drugs from online pharmacies in China. Frontiers in Medicine. 2022 Jul 19; 9:913214. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2022.913214
13. Soboleva MS, Loskutova EE, Kosova IV. Problems of purchasing pharmacy products through online orders. Journal of Advanced Pharmaceutical Technology & Research. 2022 Oct-Dec; 13(4):286-90. doi: 10.4103/japtr.japtr_454_22
14. Ziying С, Tyurina Е, Filatov А. Model for creating online consumers confidence in e-commerce. Izvestiya DVFU. Ekonomika i upravlenie. 2019; 4:42-59. doi: 10.24866/2311-2271/2019-4/42-59
15. Tunkevichus EO, Rebiazina VA. Multidimensional model for digital trust of digital services users: results of the empirical research. Lomonosov Economics Journal. 2023; 58(4):165-200. doi: 10.55959/MSU0130-0105-6-58-4-8
16. Evjemo B, Castejón-Martínez H, Akselsen S. Trust trumps concern: findings from a seven-country study on consumer consent to 'digital native' vs. 'digital immigrant' service providers. Behaviour and Information Technology. 2019; 38(5):503-18. doi: 10.1080/0144929X.2018.1541254
17. Singh Y, Eisenberg MD, Sood N. Factors associated with public trust in pharmaceutical manufacturers. JAMA Network Open. 2023; 6(3):e233002. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.3002
18. Edelman trust index worldwide based on average trust in selected institutions in 2023 and 2024, by country. Statista. Available at: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1362818/trust-index-edelman/#:~:text=The%20Edelman%20trust%20index%20of,had%20scores%20under%2040%20percent (accessed on August 28, 2024).
19. Radaev VV. Millenialy: kak menyaetsya rossiiskoe obshchestvo [Millennials: how Russian society is changing]. Izd. dom Vysshei shkoly ekonomiki, Moscow. 2019; 224 p.
20. The Future of Tech and AI According to Salesforce – Predictions & Trends to Watch in 2024. Salesforce. November 28, 2023. Available at: https://www.salesforce.com/uk/news/stories/future-of-salesforce/?ysclid=lzmma4djxp305157946 (accessed on August 28, 2024).
21. Nurmukhametov RK, Torin SS. Tsifrovoe doverie (digital trust): sushchnost i mery po ego povysheniyu [Digital trust: its essence and measures to increase it]. Izvestiya Tulskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Ekonomicheskie I Yuridicheskie Nauki. 2020; 1:32-9.
22. Bondarenko SА. Implementation of the strategy of state consumer rights protection policy for the period up to 2030 in the norms of private and public law. Altaiskii Vestnik Gosudarstvennoi I Munitsipalnoi Sluzhby. 2021; 19:47-9.
23. Khramtsov АВ. Сurrent problems in the sphere of consumer protection. Siberian Journal of Economics and Management. 2018; 7(2):129-43. doi: 10.12731/2070-7568-2018-2-129-143
24. Order of the Government of the Russian Federation of August 28, 2017, No. 1837-r "On approval of the Strategy of the state policy of the Russian Federation in the field of consumer protection for the period up to 2030". Sobranie Zakonodatel’stva Rossiiskoi Federatsii [SZ RF] [Collection of Legislation of the RF] 11.09.2017, No. 37, Item 5543.
25. Bevan M, Ng YC, Cooper J, Robertson J, Walkom E, Chiu S, Newby DA. The role of evidence in consumer choice of non-prescription medicines. International Journal of Pharmacy Practice. 2019 Dec; 27(6):501-9. doi: 10.1111/ijpp.12546
26. Jiang H, Mi Z, Xu W. Online medical consultation service-oriented recommendations: systematic review. Journal of Medical Internet Research. 2024 Jul 30; 26:e46073. doi: 10.2196/46073
27. Prosvirkin GA, Dorofeeva VV. Analiz uslugi distantsionnogo konsultirovaniya v aptechnykh onlain-servisakh [Analyzing the implementation of remote consultation in online pharmacies]. Pharmacy. 2024; 3:38-42. doi: 10.29296/25419218-2024-03-06
28. Guo Y Digital trust and the reconstruction of trust in the digital society: an integrated model based on trust theory and expectation confirmation theory. Digital Government Research and Practice. 2022; 3(4): 26. doi: 10.1145/3543860
29. Parasuraman A, Zeithaml VA, Berry LL. A conceptual model of service quality and its implications for future research. Journal of Marketing. 1985; 49(4): 41-50. doi: 10.2307/1251430
30. Chesnokova NN, Kononova SV. The use of information technology in pharmaceutical consulting. Remedium. 2019; 6: 34-7.
31. Huang W, Ong WC, Wong MKF, Ng EYK, Koh T, Chandramouli C, Ng CT, Hummel Y, Huang F, Lam CSP, Tromp J. Applying the UTAUT2 framework to patients’ attitudes toward healthcare task shifting with artificial intelligence. BMC Health Services Research. 2024; 24:455. doi: 10.1186/s12913-024-10861-z
32. Palas JU, Sorwar G, Hoque MR, Sivabalan A. Factors influencing the elderly's adoption of mHealth: an empirical study using extended UTAUT2 model. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making. 2022 Jul 24; 22(1):191. doi: 10.1186/s12911-022-01917-3
33. Salgado T, Tavares J, Oliveira T. Drivers of mobile health acceptance and use from the patient perspective: Survey study and quantitative model development. JMIR Mhealth and Uhealth. 2020 Jul 09; 8(7):e17588. doi: 10.2196/17588
34. Schretzlmaier P, Hecker A, Ammenwerth E. Predicting mHealth acceptance using the UTAUT2 technology acceptance model: a mixed-methods approach. Studies in Health Technology and Inform.atics 2023 May 2; 301:26-32. doi: 10.3233/SHTI230007
35. Turcotte S, Bouchard C, Rousseau J, DeBroux Leduc R, Bier N, Kairy D, Dang-Vu TT, Sarimanukoglu K, Dubé F, Bourgeois Racine C, Rioux C, Shea C, Filiatrault J. Factors influencing older adults' participation in telehealth interventions for primary prevention and health promotion: a rapid review. Australasian Journal of Ageing. 2024 Mar; 43(1):11-30. doi: 10.1111/ajag.13244
36. Alam MZ, Hoque MR, Hu W, Barua Z. Factors influencing the adoption of mHealth services in a developing country: a patient-centric study. International Journal of Information Management. 2020; 50(2):128-43. doi: 10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2019.04.016
37. Liu JYW, Sorwar G, Rahman MS, Rakibul Hoque R. The role of trust and habit in the adoption of mHealth by older adults in Hong Kong: a healthcare technology service acceptance (HTSA) model. BMC Geriatrics. 2023 Feb 4; 23(1):73. doi:.1186/s12877-023-03779-4
38. Tamilmani K, Rana NP, Dwivedi YK. Consumer acceptance and use of information technology: a meta-analytic evaluation of UTAUT2. Information Systems Frontiers. 2021; 23(5):987-1005. doi: 10.1007/s10796-020-10007-6
39. Schomakers EM, Lidynia C, Vervier LS, Valdez AC, Ziefle M. Applying an extended UTAUT2 model to explain user acceptance of lifestyle and therapy mobile health apps: survey study. JMIR Mhealth and Uhealth. 2022; 10(1):e27095. doi: 10.2196/27095
40. Chereches MC, Popa СО. Online pharmacy: customer profiling. Acta Marisiensis - Seria Medica. 2021 Dec 30; 67(4):221-6. doi: 10.2478/amma-2021-0031
41. Gharaibeh L, Alameri MA, Al-Kabariti AY, Alsa'd AA, Abed A, Karameh N. Practices, perceptions and trust of the public regarding online drug purchasing: a web-based survey from Jordan. BMJ Open. 2023; 13(10):e077555. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2023-077555
42. Mirzaei A, Carter SR, Chen JY, Rittsteuer C, Schneider CR. Development of a questionnaire to measure consumers’ perceptions of service quality in community pharmacies. Research in Social and Administrative Pharmacy. 2019 Apr; 15(4):346-57. doi: 10.1016/j.sapharm.2018.05.005
43. Nefidova OG., Babaskin DV, Litvinova TM, Babaskina LI, Glazkova IU, Savinova OV. Impact of changes in the rules of registration of medicines by the EAEU on the regulation of the turnover of medicines on its territory. Research Journal of Pharmacy and Technology. 2024; 17(6):2681-8. doi: 10.52711/0974-360X.2024.00420
44. Roblek V, Bach MP, Meško M, Bertoncelj A. To click or to buy over the counter drugs: exploring the behaviour of Slovenian customers. International Journal of Electronic Marketing and Retailing. 2018; 9(2):145-66. doi: 10.1504/IJEMR.2018.090890
45. Bahari G, Mutambik I, Almuqrin A, Alharbi ZH. Trust: how it affects the use of telemedicine in improving access to assistive technology to enhance healthcare services. Risk Management and Healthcare Policy. 2024 Jul 24; 17:1859-73. doi: 10.2147/RMHP.S469324
46. Cao Y, Zhang J, Ma L, Qin X, Li J. Examining user's initial trust building in mobile online health community adopting. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2020 Jun 2; 17(11):3945. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17113945
47. Hong Z, Deng Z, Zhang W. Examining factors affecting patients trust in online healthcare services in China: the moderating role of the purpose of use. Health Informatics Journal. 2019 Dec; 25(4):1647-60. doi: 10.1177/1460458218796660
48. Mansoor M. Citizens' trust in government as a function of good governance and government agency's provision of quality information on social media during COVID-19. Government Information. 2021: 38(4):101597. doi: 10.1016/j.giq.2021.101597
49. Xu Y, Yang Z, Jiang H, Sun P. Research on patients' willingness to conduct online health consultation from the perspective of web trust model. Frontiers in Public Health. 2022 Sep 09; 10:963522. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2022.963522
50. Yang M, Jiang J, Kiang M, Yuan F. Re-examining the impact of multidimensional trust on patients’ online medical consultation service continuance decision. Information Systems Frontiers. 2022; 24: 983-1007. doi: 10.1007/s10796-021-10117-9
51. Tyurina EA. Tsao Ts. Doverie onlain-potrebitelei: sravnitelnaya otsenka i model formirovaniya (na primere Rossii i Kitaya) [Online consumer trust: a comparative assessment and formation model (based on the examples of Russia and China)]. Rossiiskii zhurnal menedzhmenta. 2023; 21(3): 344-76. doi: 10.21638/spbu18.2023.303
52. Somil Gupta, Shourya Gupta. New product launch through social media and point of sale promotion. Asian J. Management 5(2): April-June, 2014 page 183-187.
53. Shobha Menon, Manoj Edward. Motivations and Performance of Exhibitors: An Exploratory Study of a Destination Marketing Event. Asian J. Management; 2017; 8(2): 315-323..
54. Neeti Gupta. Digital Marketing: Trends, Opportunities, and Challenges. Asian Journal of Management. 2020; 11(4): 434-440.
|
Received on 17.10.2024 Revised on 13.02.2025 Accepted on 15.04.2025 Published on 02.05.2025 Available online from May 07, 2025 Research J. Pharmacy and Technology. 2025;18(5):2363-2370. DOI: 10.52711/0974-360X.2025.00338 © RJPT All right reserved
|
|
|
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Creative Commons License. |
|